The Light Versions seem alot worse to me because INT and AGI isn't the best combination of stats for any character. However for STR and INT gives any character a nice boost in survivability and a nice load of extra mana/spellpower, I would pass this weapon straight to Phodom of course.
Side note does the Heavy Damned Maximillian really have 24 Armor, 8 more than all the others or is that a typo?